Have We Taken Participation Too Far? – Servant of Chaos

« Five Must-Read Posts from Last Week |

Have We Taken ‘Participation’ Too Far?


I came across this interesting letter on Katie Chatfield’s blog. It purports to be an open letter from “Brian” to the marketing industry. But whether it actually IS from a real person or not, the sentiment certainly resonates with people.

Now, because I hope/expect/want people to participate in the programs or marketing that I put together, I try to participate where I can. I contribute content and content, I comment and retweet and share. Sometimes I even do a mashup. But I do that out of a sense of reciprocity – not necessarily out of a sense of fun. Unless, of course, someone else puts the fun “in” – a good example being the @oldspice campaign. But I am predisposed towards participation – many people are not. And as “Brian” suggests, sometimes a social activation for your brand is either not relevant or (at worst) lame, but the same can be said of microsites lovingly built for the dozen or so people who actually visit.


So, the question we should ask ourselves is – have we taken participation too far? Is “Brian” right? Or are we just not trying hard enough?

Stumble It!Share on FacebookDigg This!Save to del.icio.usEmail thisTwit This!


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Have We Taken ‘Participation’ Too Far?:



DDsD said…

I bet this is a stunt by some ad agency.. #justsayin


Luke Arms said…

Brian might have a point, but it’s not like anyone is holding a gun to his head and insisting he visit the sausage microsite, or any other.


Matthew Gain said…

I love that letter! Hilarious isn’t it.


Mandi said…

Brian must talk to my sister. My sister is not a fan of word of mouth as a lead generation target. She is convinced that she is never influenced by anyone’s opinion and makes her own decisions. I think there’s a disconnect between a product recommendation and anyone who is influenced by word of mouth is a sheep.

As much as I like where Brian is coming from, I doubt he was ever the kind of guy who would call the 1500 competition line or fill out the entry form at the local fish and chippie. Marketers still use competitions to get what they need from a campaign, mostly awareness and data. Hopefully if marketers are using UGC as a competition mechanic it’s because they need content.


Mandi said…

Ooof! Me good grammar write. Apologies!


Rich said…

Great letter, but agree with some of the comments that he obviously is not the target market for that campaign, but maybe he is cause he is certainly going to remember that brand of sausages as it moved him enough to write a letter!


Sean said…

Hey Gavin,

I think we need to spend more time thinking about purpose.

And what we ask of our fans or audiences needs to be in alignment with this purpose. Both from a congruence and a level of effort point of view.

I would type more but typing sorta sucks on the iPad. 🙂

Comment below or sign in with TypePad Facebook Twitter and more…


View the entire comment thread.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s